Xpece ONE vs Garmin Livescope: Do You Actually Need Both?
Garmin Livescope shows you what's below. The Xpece ONE puts your bait there. Here's how they compare, when you need one vs the other, and what serious anglers are choosing in 2026.
If you've been researching fishing tech lately, you've probably asked this question: do I get a Garmin Livescope, a fishing drone, or somehow both? It's a legitimate question — both tools promise to help you find and catch more fish, both carry serious price tags, and at first glance they seem to do similar things.
They don't. Livescope and the Xpece ONE solve fundamentally different problems. Understanding the difference will save you money and make you a better angler. Here's the full breakdown.
Livescope shows you where fish are. The Xpece ONE gets your bait to them — at distances no cast can reach. They complement each other, but if you fish from shore, the Xpece ONE delivers results Livescope alone never can.
What each tool actually does
Garmin Livescope
Livescope is a forward and down-scanning sonar system that gives you a live, real-time view of fish, structure, and bottom composition — all displayed on a Garmin chartplotter. It's one of the most advanced fish-finding technologies available to recreational anglers, and it genuinely changed how boat anglers locate fish.
The key word is boat. Livescope is a transducer-based system that mounts to your boat and reads what's below or ahead as you move through the water. Without a boat in the water, it does nothing. It tells you where fish are — but it can't move your bait a single inch.
Xpece ONE fishing drone
The Xpece ONE is a purpose-built fishing drone that physically carries your bait 300–500 yards offshore and drops it with one button press. It doesn't just show you where fish are — it closes the distance between you and them, from the beach, with no boat required.
It also includes an underwater camera with live video feed transmitted directly to its waterproof remote — giving you real-time visibility of bottom structure, depth changes, and bait fish activity before every drop.
The Xpece ONE remote: live underwater video, bait release control, and return-to-home — all in one waterproof unit.
Head-to-head comparison
| Feature | Xpece ONE | Garmin Livescope |
|---|---|---|
| Works without a boat | ✓ | ✗ |
| Gets bait offshore | ✓ Up to 500 yds | ✗ |
| Live underwater video | ✓ Built in | Sonar only |
| Shows fish location | Via camera | ✓ Real-time sonar |
| Works in saltwater surf | ✓ Fully sealed | Boat only |
| FAA Remote ID | ✓ Embedded | N/A |
| Bait placement precision | ✓ GPS drop | ✗ |
| Works for shore anglers | ✓ | ✗ |
| Entry price | $2,299 | $1,699+ |
Which one wins — by fishing scenario
Livescope is completely irrelevant here — it needs a boat in the water to function. The Xpece ONE is in its element: it carries your bait past the surf zone to structure and depth changes that are impossible to reach by casting. For every shore angler, the drone is the only tool that actually moves the needle.
In a bass boat on a lake or shallow river, Livescope's real-time sonar picture is one of the most powerful tools available. You can see fish suspended in cover, track their movement, and watch your lure as it falls. In this context, a drone adds little — you can already position the boat precisely and cast accurately to the fish Livescope reveals.
For large species that hold in offshore structure and depth transitions, getting bait to the right spot is the entire challenge. Livescope shows you what's there — but without a boat, you still can't reach it. The Xpece ONE's 7 lb bait release handles full shark rigs and drops them exactly where the camera shows fish and structure activity.
If you fish from a boat across multiple environments — inshore, offshore, and surf — there's a genuine case for both. Livescope gives you the sonar picture from the boat. The Xpece ONE extends your reach when you anchor up and want to drop bait further than you can cast, or when you're shore fishing on the same trip. They don't compete — they cover different moments in the same session.
The Xpece ONE in flight — closing the distance between shore angler and offshore fish with a 7 lb bait release and live camera feed.
The camera question: does the Xpece ONE replace Livescope?
This is where most comparisons get lazy. Livescope is a sonar system — it uses sound waves to build a real-time picture of fish and structure in any water clarity. The Xpece ONE uses an optical underwater camera — it shows you what the lens can see in available light.
In clear, shallow water, the Xpece ONE camera gives you excellent visibility of bottom structure, bait fish schools, and depth transitions. In murky or dark water, sonar wins — it sees regardless of visibility. So for pure fish-finding capability in all conditions, Livescope's sonar is more powerful.
But here's the thing: for shore anglers, Livescope's superior fish-finding ability is irrelevant because you can't act on the information anyway. Knowing there are sharks at 400 yards doesn't help you if your cast reaches 60. The Xpece ONE's camera is good enough to identify productive drop zones, and the drone actually gets you there.
Price reality check
A base Garmin Livescope system (transducer + chartplotter) starts around $1,699 and quickly climbs past $2,500 with mounting hardware, installation, and a compatible chartplotter if you don't already have one. And that's before you have a boat to put it on.
The Xpece ONE is $2,299 — complete. Drone, waterproof remote, underwater camera, carrying case, battery, and embedded FAA Remote ID. No installation. No boat required. Free shipping across the US in 1–4 days.
For shore anglers comparing the two, the math is simple: one tool works for you, the other requires infrastructure you may not have.
The result: a shark caught from the beach, no boat, no charter — just the Xpece ONE and the right drop spot.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Xpece ONE a fish finder?
Not in the sonar sense. The Xpece ONE includes a live underwater camera that shows you bottom structure, depth changes, and bait fish activity — but it uses optical imaging, not sonar. In clear water it's highly effective for identifying productive drop zones. For sonar-based fish finding in any water clarity, Garmin Livescope is the dedicated tool.
Can I use Garmin Livescope from the shore?
No. Livescope is a transducer-based system that requires a boat in the water to function. It has no application for shore, surf, or beach fishing. The Xpece ONE is purpose-built for shore fishing and works without any boat or watercraft.
Does the Xpece ONE show fish on a screen like Livescope?
The Xpece ONE shows live optical video on the waterproof remote's screen — you can see fish visually if they're within camera range and water clarity allows. Livescope uses sonar to show fish as targets regardless of water clarity. The Xpece ONE camera is excellent for scouting structure and drop zones; Livescope is more powerful for tracking individual fish in real time.
Do serious anglers use both?
Some do — particularly those who fish from a boat across multiple environments. Livescope provides the sonar picture from the boat; the Xpece ONE extends bait placement reach when anchored or fishing from shore on the same trip. They solve different problems and don't directly compete.
Which is better value for a shore angler?
The Xpece ONE — by a significant margin. Livescope requires a boat to function and doesn't help a shore angler at all. The Xpece ONE at $2,299 includes everything needed to fish from the beach, reach fish 300–500 yards offshore, and see bottom structure before every drop — no boat, no installation, no additional hardware.
See it. Reach it.
Catch it.
Free shipping across the US in 1–4 days. 30-day money-back guarantee.
SHOP THE XPECE ONE →